A reader suggests the following potential replacements for Wolfe's important concept that "Each individual adopts a set of values which, if truly absolute in the world--so ordained by some almighty force--would make not that individual but his group . . . the best of all possible groups, the best of all inner circles."
Hopefully         one of these buzzwords for "fiction absolute" might pull it         off:
     
       Vanity paradigm
     
       Group-hype
     
       egocosmos
     
       hypeomology
     
       This little insight would explain much about why Black-American media         culture so adamantly condemns assimilated, by-the-book blacks as         "acting white". If a critical mass of blacks decides to abide         by the White egocosmos, it will damage the credibility of its black         counterpart, and thus compell (eventually) blacks to accept being in         second place in the dominant paradigm. Thus where going by the book         might be the better individual strategy, the preservation of group         vanity requires the instillment of an alternative paradigm reflecting         the endowments of African-Americans, where they come in first and whites         in second.
Any other         suggestions?
     
       Reader comments:
I think that 'egocosmos' takes it. A nice, smooth neologism that emphasizes the rootedness of the social myth in the inner urges, anxieties, and will-to-power of the subjects.
*
Thinking about Wolfe's idea, I like the terms "group primacy," "club primacy," or to come at it differently "The Perfect Circle." It could be given a more scientific note if we Latinzed it "Orbis Superbia."
*
What the heck is "hypeomology?"
*
"Ideal type" I know, Max Weber used it in another sense, but since it has zero recognition in the general culture I say it is open.
How about three-word phrases? This isn't an easy concept to get across, so maybe we should try being a little more expansive.
Tribal narcissism
"Tribal" is very good. "Narcissism" is close, but it sounds too self-contained, too aloof, whereas this phenomenon is more competitive, more relative, more needing to put other groups down to promote your own.
Vanity Paradigm
"Vanity"  pays tribute to Wolfe's "Bonfire of the Vanities," although there  Wolfe was using "vanity," I would assume, in the sense of Ecclesiastes  and/or Savonarola, "Vanity of vanities, all is vanity," rather than in  the more contemporary sense of egotistical.
I think Wolfe is drawing an analogy to Kant's philosophically sophisticated version of the Golden Rule, the Categorical Imperative, which says "Act only according to that maxim by which you can at the same time will  that it would become a universal law."  (Another version: "Act  so that the maxim ... may be capable of becoming a universal law for all  rational beings.")
Wolfe's "fiction-absolute" is the evil twin of the categorical  imperative:          "Each individual adopts a set of values which, if truly absolute in          the world--so ordained by some almighty force--would make not that          individual but his group . . . the best of all possible groups, the best          of all inner circles." In other words, "Act so that if  the maxim became a universal law for all rational beings, your group must be  seen as best."
So, maybe some term calling attention to the contrast with Kant's categorical  imperative might help, such as "competitive imperative." I kind of  like "tribal competitive imperative."
My published articles are archived at iSteve.com -- Steve Sailer
 
 
 
 Posts
Posts
 
 
 
 
 
 
No comments:
Post a Comment